Milltown, NJ · Made fresh to order
A little piece of
happiness in every bite
Sweet Smile Bakery specializes in delicious tres leches cakes and coconut ice cream, made with high‑quality ingredients and lots of love.
Meet the baker
Hi, I'm Sara — welcome to Sweet Smile
I'm 16, a student at East Brunswick High School, and baking has been my passion for as long as I can remember. It started small — selling desserts to friends and classmates at school — and grew into something I couldn't stop thinking about.
Now I'm so excited to grow that into a small business, sharing my homemade tres leches cakes and coconut ice cream with the Milltown community and nearby towns. Every order is made with quality ingredients, care, and lots of love. My goal is simple: every single bite should be delicious and memorable.
“Made with love, by Sara.”
Fan favorites
What we're known for
A short menu, made properly. Ask about seasonal flavors and custom orders for birthdays and celebrations.
Signature tres leches
Cute · $30.00
Medium · $60.00
Large · $90.00
Coconut popsicle
Creamy house-made coconut popsicle, the perfect refreshing treat alongside any slice.
Custom celebration cakes
Birthdays, showers, and special occasions — tell us the flavor and we'll bring the smiles.
Custom ordersSimple, personal, sweet
How to order
We take every order personally — message us directly and we'll walk you through flavors, sizes, and pickup or delivery.
Browse the menu
Take a look at our signature cakes and ice cream above for inspiration.
Send us a message
DM us on Instagram, Facebook, or WhatsApp with your flavor, size, and date.
Confirm and enjoy
We'll confirm details, pricing, and pickup or delivery — then bake with love.
Kind words
What our customers say
A few notes from happy customers — replace with real reviews as they come in.
“The tres leches was the best I've had — not too sweet, perfectly soaked.”
Sample review · Google
“Ordered a custom cake for my daughter's birthday and it was stunning and delicious.”
Sample review · Google
“Ordering through Instagram was so easy and the coconut ice cream is addictive.”
Sample review · Google
@sweetsmilebakerynj
Follow the sweetness
Behind-the-scenes bakes, new flavors, and daily treats — connect below.